主题: 俄罗斯再次炮击了许多乌克兰城市。现在是不是时候开始报复性攻击俄罗斯城市,把它们夷为平地,因为事情已经坏到头了,70%的俄罗斯人都支持战争?
Russia has again shelled numerous Ukrainian cities. Is it time for them to start attacking Russian cities in retaliation and burning them to the ground, as things cannot get any worse, with 70% of Russians supporting the war?
答主:Carl Hamilton, M.S. in Geography & History, Roskilde University (Graduated 2021)
First of all, Russian cities has been shelled already, and they have been for as long as it has been possible to hit them with artillery in this war. Shelling a city doesn’t make it disappear. A city will not be burned to the ground due to shelling, unless that shelling is long term and extensive. If Ukraine ups strikes against Russian civilians, Russia will do the same to Ukraine. This is called tit for tat. Is this really a competition you want Ukraine or anyone else to engage in? The result will not be less Russian support for the war, it will be more Russian hatred for Ukrainians, and more Ukrainian hatred for Russians. And of course a whole lot more dead civilians. Why would you want this? You see things can always get worse.
首先,俄罗斯城市已经受到炮击了,并且在这场战争中,乌克兰已经运用了炮兵部队的最大射程去攻击城市。炮击一座城市并不会让它消失。一座城市不会因为炮击而被夷为平地,除非炮击持续很久、规模巨大。如果乌克兰提高对俄罗斯民众的打击力度,俄罗斯也会对乌克兰做同样的事。这叫做以牙还牙。这真的是你希望乌克兰或其他任何人参与进去的对抗吗?它不可能使俄罗斯支持战争的人数减少,而是会制造更多俄罗斯人对乌克兰人的仇恨,反之亦然。当然,还会造成更巨大的平民死亡。为什么你会希望这样?你看,事情总是还有变坏的空间。
Kyiv 2023
基辅 2023
Marinka 2023
马林卡 2023
I would argue this is what worse looks like. Marinka has been fought over since 2014, and there is nothing left. I do not recommend attempting to expand the list of cities that looks like this to any additional names if at all possible.
我认为这就是那个更坏的样子。马林卡从2014年起就一直在经历战斗,那里已经什么都不剩了。如果可能的话,我不建议尝试把任何新的名字写进变成这样的城市的名单中。
译自:https://qr.ae/prJNli
时间:2023年3月9日